The Comforters – A Review

As per my last blog post I was sent 4 Muriel Spark books by Berlinn as part of a Year of Muriel Spark.

The Comforters is the first I’ve read.


Caroline Rose is plagued by the tapping of typewriter keys and the strange, detached narration of her every thought and action. She has an unusual problem – she realises she is in a novel. Her fellow characters are also possibly deluded: Laurence, her former lover, finds diamonds in a loaf of bread – could his elderly grandmother really be a smuggler? And Baron Stock, her bookseller friend, believes he is on the trail of England’s leading Satanist.

This is the metafictional surrealism that is promised, but Spark delivers much more and the metafiction isn’t the strongest thread. This is Spark’s first novel and her prose style is already accomplished but occasionally it does feel a little undercooked. For example  there is a car crash (minor spoiler) which is over in a sentence. Some of the relationshps don’t stand up to too much scrutiny and the end of the crime caper sub-plot seems a little contrived. But it’s still an entertaining read despite a few flaws because of the prose and the humour.

The granny who hides diamonds in bread, the satanist sub-plot and the bizarre familial relations are reminiscent of Ealing comedies. The plot also relies heavily on a Catholic conversion (Spark converted to Catholicism) and was the metafiction a device or a commentary on mental illness?

In all an odd debut but an enjoyable one. I’m looking forward to diving into her second book: Robinson



Published by suttope

Pete Sutton has a not so secret lair in the wilds of Fishponds, Bristol and dreams up stories, many of which are about magpies. He's had stuff published, online and in book form, and currently has a pile of words that one day may possibly be a novel. He wrote all about Fishponds for the Naked Guide to Bristol and has made more money from non-fiction than he has from fiction and wonders if that means the gods of publishing are trying to tell him something. You can find him all over social media or worrying about events he’s organised at the Bristol Festival of Literature. On Twitter he’s @suttope and his Bristol Book Blog is here: He's contributing editor of Far Horizons e-magazine which can be found here:

One thought on “The Comforters – A Review

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: